Mediacritic

This article is a stub:
It is very small and that makes us sad. Please help us expand it.

Create a "MediaCritic" chart of various media/journalism websites, and list and score how well they follow the proposed ethics guideline below.

References

reuters.com Standards and Values - use this as a base
- Blog post of a Reuters journalist on the failure of game media
spj.com - Society of Professional Journalists
rjionline.org - Canada Code: Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Journalistic Standards and Practices
escapistmagazine.com The Escapist's Ethics Policy
polygon.com - Polygon's Ethics Policy
[1]
add others

Organize categories from the guides above.
- Add and remove categories as needed, related to gaming
Someone with good spreadsheet-fu should set up a page on Google Drive
- Give a weight of 0 to 1 on each item
- List reference articles from various sites for and against to give a score (i.e. 4 follows, 2 do not = 0.66 for that entry)
- And a supplementary form page to allow people to submit to add, update or correct entries
Tally it up and give a score on how trustworthy, balanced and such that site is.

Questions?

Do we list networks as one or separate? (i.e. Gawker as a whole, or separate into individual sites?)

Example format:

SomeGamerWebsite.com

Issue

For

Against

Result

Fact Checking

[1]

[1] [2] [3]

0.25

Error Corrections

[1] [2]

[1]

0.66

etc.

Score out of 120

32.5